House Speaker House John Boehner of Ohio speaks on Capitol Hill in Washington, Wednesday, Jan. 18, 2012, as the House returned to work from its winter recess. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite)
WASHINGTON (AP) - On the defensive, the White House scrambled
Thursday to explain its requirement that church-affiliated employers cover birth control after House Speaker John Boehner called it unconstitutional and demanded immediate reconsideration.
Under President Barack Obama's health care overhaul law, most
employers and insurance plans will have to cover birth control free of charge as a preventive service for women. The administration had
already ruled that churches and houses of worship do not have to
follow that requirement, but officials recently announced that many
religious-affiliated institutions such as hospitals, colleges and charities must comply.
The wave of protest that followed has clearly taken administration officials by surprise. Catholic and Protestant evangelical leaders criticized the decision as infringing on freedom of religion. Some religious liberals called it politically risky for Obama in a close election year.
"I think this mandate violates our Constitution," Boehner, R-Ohio, said Thursday. "I think it violates the rights of these religious organizations. And I would hope that the administration would back up and take another look at this." Boehner is Catholic.
White House spokesman Jay Carney said the decision will stand.
That's unlikely to silence critics. Also joining in disapproval was a group that includes Democratic lawmakers who helped engineer final passage of the health care law. The group "Democrats for Life of America" represents anti-abortion lawmakers who provided the margin of victory for passage of the health care overhaul.
"Forcing religious institutions to provide insurance coverage for services that are directly in opposition to their moral beliefs is very clearly wrong," said Kristen Day, the group's executive director.
At the White House, Carney defended the decision, saying it was the best policy to promote the health of women, and the president has no intention of trespassing on religious liberty.
"There was extensive and careful consideration as this policy was developed and a decision was made. And the issue here is we want to be sure women, all women, have access to good health care," Carney said.
Asked if there's a debate within the administration about reconsidering, Carney responded:
"No, there's not a debate. ... We want to work with organizations for the next year to help them deal with the implementation of the policy but the decision has been made, and it was made after careful consideration."
At issue is a provision of the health care law that requires insurance plans to cover preventive care for women free of charge to the employee. Last year, an advisory panel from the respected Institute of Medicine recommended including birth control on the list, partly because it promotes maternal and child health by allowing women to space their pregnancies.
Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius agreed, issuing a new federal regulation last summer.
That rule, however, exempted houses of worship and their employees, as well as other institutions whose primary purpose is
to promote religious belief. Churches, synagogues, mosques and other places would not be required to cover contraceptives, it specified. Neither would religious organizations whose purpose is to promote belief, and that primarily employ and serve people of the same creed.
It was a different story for religious-affiliated hospitals, colleges and social agencies that serve the public broadly.
Although many of those employers had not traditionally covered birth control, the new regulation will require them to do so.
For religious-affiliated employers, the requirement will take effect August 1, 2013, and their workers in most cases will have access to coverage starting January 1, 2014.
Women working for secular enterprises from profit-making companies to government will have access to the new coverage starting January 1, 2013, in most cases.
Workplace health plans will have to cover all forms of contraception approved by the Food and Drug Administration, ranging from the pill to implantable devices to sterilization. Also covered is the morning-after pill, which can prevent pregnancy after unprotected sex and is considered as tantamount to an abortion drug by some religious conservatives.
There is no mandate, however, to cover abortions.
Last Sunday, Catholic bishops in more than 140 dioceses issued
statements denouncing the decision that were read at each weekend
Bishop William Murphy of Rockville Centre, N.Y., called the birth control coverage requirement "a radical incursion on the part of our government into freedom of conscience." Bishop David Zubik of Pittsburgh, wrote that "the Obama administration was essentially saying `to hell with you,' particularly to the Catholic community by dismissing our beliefs, our religious freedom and our freedom of conscience."
An AP-GfK poll from December found that Catholics supported Obama by 49 percent to 45 percent in a matchup with Republican
front runner Mitch Romney. But among Catholics who attend Mass
weekly, Romney had the edge by 45 percent to 52 percent.