NEW YORK (AP) - President Barack Obama's candid thoughts about
Kanye West are provoking a debate over standards of journalism in
the Twitter age.
ABC News says it was wrong for its employees to tweet that Obama
had called West a "jackass" for the rapper's treatment of country
singer Taylor Swift. The network said some of its employees had
overheard a conversation between the president and CNBC's John
Harwood and didn't realize it was considered off the record.
The network apologized to the White House and CNBC.
Harwood had sat down with the president to tape an interview
following his appearance on Wall Street on Monday. Although they
are competitors, CNBC and ABC share a fiber optic line to save
money, and this enabled some ABC employees to listen in on the
interview as it was being taped for later use.
Their attention was drawn to chatter about West, who was widely
criticized for interrupting Swift as she accepted an award at
Sunday's MTV Video Music Awards to say that Beyonce deserved it.
During what sounds like informal banter before the interview
begins, Obama is asked whether his daughters were annoyed by West's
hijacking of Swift's acceptance statement, according to an audio
copy that was posted on TMZ.com.
"I thought that was really inappropriate," Obama says. "What
are you butting in (for)? ... The young lady seems like a perfectly
nice person. She's getting her award. What's he doing up there?"
A questioner chimes in, "Why would he do it?"
"He's a jackass," Obama replies, which is met with laughter
from several people.
The president seems to quickly realize he may have gone too far,
and jovially appeals to those assembled that the remark be kept
private. "Come on guys," he says. "Cut the president some slack.
I've got a lot of other stuff on my plate."
E-mails shot around among ABC employees about Obama's comments,
said Jeffrey Schneider, ABC News spokesman. Before anything was
reported on ABC's air or Web site, at least three network employees
took to Twitter to spread the news.
One was Terry Moran, a former White House correspondent. He
logged on to Twitter and typed: "Pres. Obama just called Kanye
West a 'jackass' for his outburst at VMAs when Taylor Swift won.
Now THAT'S presidential."
When ABC News authorities found out about it, they had the
tweets deleted after about an hour, Schneider said. Moran declined
a request to comment.
But the news was out.
Harwood said there was no explicit agreement with the president
that those comments were off the record. But he said it is
broadcast tradition that such pre-interview chatter is considered
off the record until the formal interview begins. Harwood is
holding to that: He would not discuss what the president said
before their interview and has no plans to do so on CNBC.
He said he was aware that it was likely someone outside of CNBC
was listening to his conversation with the president.
"It's one of those things that's unfortunate," he said. "But
I think it's an honest mistake."
There was no immediate response to requests for comment from
White House spokesmen.
Twitter, a technology that's a natural tool for reporters who
love to tell people what they know whenever they know it, has raced
ahead in usage before many news organizations have developed
policies to govern its use, said Richard Wald, a former ABC News
executive and professor at Columbia University.
"You need to reinforce the sense that you have to verify before
you publish," Wald said. "The policies may be very comprehensive,
but they may not be adequate to the technology that news
The incident is reminiscent of past "open-mic" incidents
involving politicians. President Ronald Reagan, while waiting to
make a speech in 1984, joked that he had outlawed the Soviet Union
and that "the bombing begins in five minutes." During the 2000
presidential campaign, George W. Bush turned to running mate Dick
Cheney to point out a reporter from The New York Times and used an
obscenity to describe him.
"If you're sitting there with a microphone on, you don't have a
reasonable expectation of privacy," said Kelly McBride, an expert
in journalism ethics for the Poynter Institute. "If you're a
governor or president, you know that."
She also questioned whether news organizations should be
agreeing to go off the record with the president.
Judging by the things written by other Twitter users since
West's action, Obama wasn't in the minority, she said.
"The president calling Kanye West a 'jackass' is perfect
information for a tweet," she said. "In fact, that's the ideal
format. You can do it in 140 characters. There's not much else to