VATICAN CITY (AP) - Pope Benedict XVI told Irish bishops at a special summit meeting Tuesday to be courageous in confronting the pedophile priest scandal that has rocked that Catholic nation's church, but took no action on victims' demands the Vatican take some responsibility.
Specifically, bishops said the pope didn't rule on whether to accept the resignations offered by several bishops for their role in decades of concealment or push for resignations from those resisting calls to step down.
The two-day, closed-door meeting bringing together the pope, top
Vatican officials and 24 Irish bishops was called to restore the
trust of Irish Catholics shaken by revelations of decades of clergy
sex abuse and cover-up.
"While realizing that the current painful situation will not be
resolved quickly, (Benedict) challenged the bishops to address the
problems of the past with determination and resolve, and to face
the present crisis with honesty and courage," according to a
Within hours ago, activists troubled by what they contend is a
pattern of Vatican denial of responsibility were branding the talks
"It's heartbreaking that the resignation of callous, deceptive
bishops wasn't even discussed at this meeting," said Barbara
Blaine, head of the U.S.-based Survivors Network of those Abused by
A Vatican spokesman, the Rev. Federico Lombardi, said the pope
"shares the outrage" over the abuse and noted he had "already
expressed profound regret," but that the issue of resignations
"was not addressed."
Irish Church leader Cardinal Sean Brady told reporters that one
bishop who has bucked demands to resign, Martin Drennan of Galway,
"has made his position clear" and that the summit wasn't meant to
Victims had already warned the talks would be a failure unless
the pope demanded resignations of bishops who had any role in
concealing wrongdoing. They also demand that the pope accept in
full the findings of the Irish investigations, which some church
officials in Ireland have criticized as unfair.
Pressed by reporters whether there was any admission by the
Vatican at the summit that Rome shared in the responsibility of
what victims call a "culture of concealment," Brady ventured that
the summit, "with all that time in listening and responding would
indicate some degree of responsibility" is felt by the Vatican.
But the Vatican's statement, while noting that Benedict called
the sexual abuse of children "a heinous crime," only spoke of the
"failure of Irish church authorities for many years to act
effectively" in cases of sexual abuse of young people by Irish
clergy and religious.
Ireland's bishops, while brushing off reporters' suggestions
they were somehow scapegoats for the Vatican's policies aimed at
looking after its clergy, seemed intent at looking for blame in the
Irish church hierarchy.
"We are coming from a culture of secrecy and confidentiality,
which was admittedly overemphasized in the past," said Clogher
Bishop Joseph Duffy.
During the summit, anger flared in Ireland over the refusal of
papal envoy Archbishop Giuseppe Leanza to appear in the Irish
Lombardi defended Leanza, saying the envoy was simply following
rules about diplomatic privilege. "If this is not part of his
duty, you can't expect him" to testify, he said.
Later, bishops said the Vatican was worried that having the
pope's diplomatic representatives answer to lawmakers would set a
"It would be very difficult to have (Leanza's) grilling in
front of a parliamentary committee," Bishop Brendan Kelly of
Leanza has faced heavy criticism in Ireland for ignoring letters
from two state-ordered investigations into how the church
suppressed reports of child abuse by parish priests and in
Catholic-run residences for poor children.
Lombardi said the pope would send Irish faithful a letter about
the crisis during Lent, the period of penitence, which ends this
year on April 4, Easter Sunday.
Bishops said the letter will address the victims.
Asked if the pope would meet with victims either at the Vatican
or on some future trip to Ireland, Ferns Bishop Denis Brennan
replied: "I'm sure he'll be ready to meet victims in Ireland when
the time is right."
In their meeting with Benedict, "the bishops spoke frankly of
their sense of pain and anger, betrayal, scandal and shame
expressed to them on numerous occasions by those who had been
abused," according to the Vatican statement.
The bishops were heading back to their homeland in time to lead
Ash Wednesday services.
Brady said Irish church leaders needed to do penitence for the
scandal that would be "the equivalent of sackcloth and ashes" and
have a "change of heart."
(Copyright 2010 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)