CAIRO (AP) - Iran clamped down Tuesday on independent media in
an attempt to control images of election protests, but pictures and
videos leaked out anyway - showing how difficult it is to shut off
the flow of information in the Internet age.
The restrictions imposed by the government made such
social-networking sites as Twitter and Flickr more prominent - with
even the U.S. State Department calling on Twitter to put off a
scheduled shutdown for maintenance.
Iranians were posting items online, but it wasn't known how much
of that information was being seen by others inside the country.
And although some of the posts on Twitter appeared to be from users
in Tehran, others clearly were not.
Following a massive opposition rally Monday, authorities
restricted journalists - including Iranians working for foreign
media - from reporting on the streets. They could effectively only
work from their offices, conducting telephone interviews and
monitoring official sources such as state TV.
Some foreign journalists were forced to leave Iran because the
government wouldn't extend the visas they received to cover
Friday's election, in which President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad was
declared the landslide winner.
"Clearly, when our journalists can't go out and see things and
talk to people, our ability to tell the story is not as good as
when we are able to go out to report and take pictures and video,"
AP Executive Editor Kathleen Carroll said.
When controls are imposed, "we work with those restrictions,
keeping in mind our ultimate goal is to be able to do our jobs as
journalists," she said.
The London-based Reuters news agency included an editor's note
on its stories out of Iran saying its coverage was subject to a ban
on "foreign media leaving the office to report, film, or take
pictures in Tehran."
CNN turned in part to the social-networking sites, broadcasting
images posted on Facebook and Twitter, and explaining on-air that
it was using "creativity" to cover a big event under government
"We cannot verify readily some of this material that we're
going to show you," correspondent David Mattingly warned viewers.
Much of the material on Twitter is posted anonymously.
CNN spokeswoman Bridget Leininger said that adding context and
explaining issues was necessary when reporting with such online
sources. "We are committed to making the most information
available in a tough news environment, while being totally
transparent with the audience," she said.
Iranian journalists have also been targeted, including at least
10 who have been arrested, according to the press freedom group
Reporters Without Borders.
"We are very worried about them," said Jean-Francois Julliard,
secretary-general of the Paris-based organization. "We don't know
where they have been detained, in what conditions. And we know as
well that bloggers have been arrested, people who just took
pictures with their mobile phones have been arrested, and all
journalists are under threat."
The Iranian government also tried to stop its citizens from
spreading information. Internet service and cell phone service was
intermittent Tuesday, with long delays getting online. Many sites,
including some that support reformist challenger Mir Hossein
Mousavi, were blocked.
Even under ideal circumstances, only a quarter of Iran's 70
million people have Internet access at home or at work, and
Internet cafes are found only in major cities.
Fearing Iranian government attempts to track Twitter users, some
of those abroad changed their settings to make it appear they're in
Iran - hoping to make it more difficult for authorities to find
Users of Twitter have also been sharing ways, called proxies,
that Iranians can use to circumvent the efforts to block sites.
The importance of Twitter in Iran has been recognized by the
U.S. State Department, which contacted the company during the
weekend to request that Twitter not take its service down for
scheduled maintenance, according to an official who spoke on
condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the situation.
San Francisco-based Twitter Inc. delayed the planned 90-minute
shutdown, citing the role Twitter was playing in Iran.
To stop citizens from getting out their text messages, tweets,
photos and e-mails, Iran would have to restrict Web access
entirely, following the footsteps of North Korea or Cuba, said John
Palfrey, an Internet censorship expert at Harvard University.
Reporters were also restricted during the 1979 Iranian
revolution, which saw the installation of the Islamic regime in
Back then, reporters relied on land lines and Telex services of
the government telecommunications company to get out the news.
Instead of relaying copy from American news organizations that
were perceived as biased in favor of the monarchy, revolutionary
sympathizers in the government would often block the Americans'
Government censors and the Internet have often clashed.
This April, protesters in Moldova used Twitter and the Internet
when mobile phones and cable news television stations went down.
Myanmar's military government has cracked down on Internet use
by dissident groups, temporarily shutting down international
connections and jailing bloggers.
"No one quite knows what sort of pressure ... would actually
lead to a free election," said Ethan Zuckerman, research fellow at
Harvard University's Berkman Center for Internet and Society.
"Certainly, international attention makes it harder to wash things
under the rug."