Mortage Broker To Investors: "I'm Taking the Fifth"
From KOLO 8 Weather Now... The National Weather Service in Reno has issued a Wind Advisory. A wind advisory will be in effect from 8 AM until 11 PM on Thursday.
Save Email Print
Bookmark and Share
Posted: 7:17 PM Sep 15, 2008
Mortage Broker To Investors: "I'm Taking the Fifth"
The owner of a failed mortgage company faced a crowd of angry investors Monday with just one answer: "I'm taking the Fifth."
Reporter: Ed Pearce
width:247 and height: 190 and picwidth: 207 and pciheight: 159
Font Size:

RENO - Monday afternoon the owner of a failed mortgage firm faced a crowd of angry investors--some of whom said they stood to lose hundreds of thousands of dollars in construction loans gone bad.

They had questions. She had just one answer.

Questions for Marcie Benvin from attorneys and investors amounted to an impressive list of potential charges. Why did some documents appear to have been altered? Did Benvin sign anyone else's name to them? Why were some just missing? The answer was always the same. Benvin stuck to a script provided by her attorney. She invoked her Fifth Amendment right to avoid self-incrimination.

Benvin's company, Cetus Mortgages, specialized in "hard money" loans for home construction. In July, the state seized the company after investors complained Cetus was not paying them, that their names had been forged and construction projects remained idle even though investors money had been loaned to developers. Cetus filed for bankruptcy and state regulators and the federal bankruptcy trustee have been trying to unravel a $60 million dollar mess ever since.

The former president of the state Association of Mortgage Brokers did read a statement blaming the problems of her company on the economy and promising to work to try to return as much as possible to her investors who appeared to be in no mood to believe her.

"We're pretty much disgusted," said Domenick Graziano. "Her opening statement was an outright lie. She should do a lot of jail time and lose a lot of sleep as far as I'm concerned."

Graziano said he will likely lose hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Some of the investors said they had invested most of their retirement funds.


Latest Comments

Posted by: A friend Location: Reno, NV on Sep 22, 2011 at 08:43 PM

The economy did take a dump. All of us in the industry feel it! I lost my job of 18 years do to this economy. Ms. Benvin had investors that were paid 9 to 10 percent on their investments. Far better than the 1 percent the banks are giving. The banks are the biggest problem we have going. Look the word "Investor" in the dictionary. No guarantees. While it was good everyone was happier than pigs in mud. Things went bad, people lost their investment. The entire community is going belly up. How many people were ripped off by different companies closing? My husband and I invested money at one time. It ended up us losing the entire amount ultimately. Why would anyone risk their retirment on an "investment"? That is not only foolish but major greed. EVERYONE lost including Ms. Benvin. She has absolutely nothing left. She was duped by a contractor that was forging and had three mortgages on each home they were selling. That started the ball rolling. Wise up and realize this was the last thing Ms. Benvin wanted to happen. Shows you how people love you while you are giving them what they want and would just rather wish you penance and/or death. It has happened all over not just Reno, Nevada.
Posted by: Lisa Location: Reno on Sep 17, 2008 at 06:09 PM

Marcie Benvin’s speech was nothing but lies! She blames the economy, oh please! Did the economy make her forge documents, commingle funds, lie, cheat & steal? NO, Marcie Benvin chose to do that herself! Her unethical, fraudulent, heartless, disgusting, dishonest behavior has put ALL of us in the positions we are in. Hundreds of Investors/Contractors/Subcontractors & their families are devastated by her actions. Our lives have been turned upside down. Marcie Benvin deserves EVERYHING she gets at the end of this and hopefully she will spend a very long time in jail!
KOLO First Alert Weather
KOLO Features
Northern Nevada Jobs
Find great local jobs here!
KOLO AP News
KOLO Blogs
Carter, Wolf Pack Deserve Our Support - Post Your Comments!
I Already Miss My Friend JK - Post Your Comments!
Joe Paterno Must Step Down - Post Your Comments!
No More "Whiteouts" - 1 Comments Posted
KUDOS to the Pack and Tyler Lantrip - Post Your Comments!
More Blogs >>>