KOLO First Alert Weather
Current Conditions
7-Day Forecast
KOLO Online Extras

The Road Ahead with RTC


Entertainment



John Tyson's Journal

Kids You Should Know

Find the lowest gas prices around town!

Medical Minutes


It's Not Just Politics

Great local and international recipes right here!

Looking for a great place to eat? Check out the Featured Restaurants or search by cuisine!

Click Here to get in the Zone.


The Children's File is available for public viewing at the KOLO-8 studios during regular business hours
Gay Marriage Changes Won't End Debate Save Email Print
Posted: 11:57 AM May 16, 2008
Last Updated: 12:11 PM May 16, 2008
Reporter: Ed Pearce

A | A | A

Like their counterparts in California, Nevada voters approved a ban on same sex marriage in a question placed on the ballot by initiative petition. Thursday's ruling by the State Supreme Court of California removing a ban on gay marriages effectively overturned a vote of the California people.

So, what effect might this decision have on this side of the state line and on the initiative process itself?

In California, the reaction expected. "Molly is in Italy and I'm asking her to marry me and she is absolutely saying she will so I could not be happier, said same sex marriage supporter Jean Rizzo, "This is a big day"

"Well we're disappointed in the ruling,” said Andrew Pugno of the Proposition 22 Defense Fund. "It was very difficult to reach which direction the court was going to go and I think that is why 1.1 million Californians went out and signed a petition to put this issue on the ballot in November to take the issue away from the courts and allow the people to decide one and for all what marriage means."

But if that measure makes the ballot and if Californians approve it will it pass muster?
Here in Reno, political scientist Fred Lokken says there are instances where not even a public vote can change the constitution.

"Can any of the language in the constitution be overturned? On the federal level we've said no. There are parts of the constitution that can't be changed even by a vote of the people or Congress or anything other than another constitutional convention."

Lokken says the ruling is unlikely to affect the initiative process here in Nevada where it's increasingly used, but he says it should give pause. It does give the voter a chance to weigh in directly on issues, he says, but that doesn't guarantee the end result will pass judicial muster or in some cases is even wise.

This appeal and this ruling was based on a reading of the California State Constitution, not the US Constitution, though the plaintiffs believe the ban also violated the federal equal protection clause.

So, if the new initiative makes it on the ballot and wins it would change the state constitution to define marriage as the union between a man and a woman. The effect of today's ruling would then be short-lived.

More debate, more legal action is almost certain.

More Stories
Search Team Finds No Sign Of Fossett

Miss Carson City Named New Miss Nevada

Nevada Republican Delegates Suing State GOP

Search for Murder Suspect Suspended

Scenic Lake Near Tahoe To Become Public Land

Exec pay soars at Sierra

Fire Torches Hidden Valley Home

Official: Nader Will Appear on Nev. Ballot

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Coming Soon: Northern Nevada Medical Center Weather Cam
KOLO Online Poll
When do you think the economy will start getting better?

Six Months
One Year
Two Years
It is doing fine


Share Your Thoughts With Us!
KOLO AP Online Videos
KOLO Blogs
I’m Told The “Dirty Thirties” Are The New Twenties - 1 Comments Posted
I’m told the “Dirty Thirties” are the new Twenties. Or maybe I’ve been watching too much “Sex And The City.” I guess either way, turning 30 can be looked at as a good thing! (Read Blog)
Happy "Losing-My-Independence" Day - 1 Comments Posted
This 4th of July started out like any other, but ended in a way that I will most definitely never forget. (Read Blog)
Reno Rodeo For The First Time - 1 Comments Posted
Being British it was a real treat to experience the Reno Rodeo for the first time, as there is nothing that compares to it back in the Isle's. (Read Blog)
Have a Heart - 6 Comments Posted
I fully believe that it’s a journalist’s responsibility to help bring light to what’s wrong in the world. To hold up a mirror to society and say “Hey. Look at yourself. Is this really the world you want to live in?” (Read Blog)
Happy Fathers Day - Post Your Comments!
Thinking about my dad this weekend, and what he's meant to me. (Read Blog)
More Blogs >>>