Is ethanol all it's cracked up to be?KOLO Blog Listing
Is ethanol all it's cracked up to be?
Topic Author: Anne Cutler
Posted: 8:00 AM May 20, 2008
Replies Posted: 8 comments
Save Email Print
 del.icio.us   Google   Yahoo  digg
Recent Blog Topics
Delle Donne Spikes Basketball
My Family just got bigger. Meet Gordo!
The "C" Word
Wolf Pack Football presented with big opportunity
What a Wonderful Getaway
Our Coverage Sometimes Causes Discomfort for the Innocent
Post Your Comments
First Name:
Email (optional):
Location:
Enter Comments:  
   characters left
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.

Is ethanol all it's cracked up to be?

Prices at the pump are so high these days, they have some consumers singing the blues.  Those sky high fuel costs are pushing researchers to find alternatives.  The higher the price of gasoline, it seems the more ideas emerge.  There are some that are a little unusual and still make some sense.

One idea that's caught on is ethanol.  By using corn for fuel, we're reducing our dependence on foreign oil and cutting down on greenhouse gas emissions.

Ethanol is advertised as a "cleaner" alternative to gasoline, but the definition of "clean" has changed.  It used to mean fewer carbon monoxide emissions.  Today, we talk about reducing green house gasses.  When you factor in the energy demand to make ethanol, there's a lot of debate about whether the fuel is actually cleaner.  There are a lot of emissions and energy uses on every step of the pathway, or "life cycle" of the ethanol.  So it takes energy to make energy.

It also takes corn.  The increased demand is causing many farmers to change their crops.  Around the world, people are getting into the business. In South America, farmers are cutting down the rainforest to clear fields.  That deforestation causes a whole host of other problems.  You have to clear the forest. there's a lot of carbon emitted in that process.  You put the land into agricultural use for the first time and there's a burst of carbon dioxide emissions that can result.

So, ethanol reduces greenhouse gasses, but creating it increases them.  It takes over a hundred years to make up for that burst of carbon dioxide from clearing the land.

Aside from the questionable environmental benefits, much of the corn traditionally used for food is now being taken out of the market. it's a problem that's entered the spotlight as we face a global food crisis.  Some say it just doesn't make sense to burn our lunch in our gas tank.  The ethanol industry defends the fuel, saying our high food prices are due to bad weather, a weak dollar, chinese demand and the high price of oil.

Experts say the benefits don't necessarily outweigh the costs, but it's a step in the right direction, toward energy independence and a cleaner, greener world.

Researchers say the future of ethanol is cellulosic feed stocks such as wood chips and rice straw.  Those use less water and fertalizer than corn and don't require coal, diesel fuel or natural gas to produce.  Cellulosic fuels are still in the development stage, but they're expected to be widespread in the fuel market, within the next 10 to 20 years. 

 

 

Read Comments
Posted by: Krysti Location: Sparks
I would like to hear more about Hydrogen Fuel cell . It sounds like the ansver to my prayers. Cut the cost more then in half on commuting and in process burn oil cleaner. KOLO had the segment on it twice and I missed both times. Somebody could make lot of money and at the same time do lot of good by instaling the Hydrogen fuel cell in cars. It is real nice to talk about all electric cars but what about those that have new cars and paid lot of money for them...junk them ?

Posted by: Randy Yates Location: Fallon,
ethanol is not cost effective when produced from corn/ food product. with exception possibly of sugar beets/ or sugar cane.

Posted by: Wendy Location: Reno
When I traveled out west in the summer of 1978, I remember buying ethanol at some gas stations. Whatever happened to that experiment? Does anyone remember this?

Posted by: Scotty Kimsley Location: W.Wendover
The diesel engine was designed to run on veg. oil and hemp oil. Henry Ford also designed the hemp car, the fabric, and plastic were hemp products and it ran and was lubricated with hemp oils and grease. Hemp oil also has a higher octane than Ehanol and cheaper to produce. The oil can also be used to make plastics, cosmetics, etc. The rest of the plant can be used in rope, fabric,building material,green fertilizes,medicines,etc. They use to call it mother natures medicine cabinet because its many and varied uses. It has been estimated that if only 10% of all ag. land was planted with Ind. Hemp we would cure our oil problem. In most areas the farmer will get 2 crops annually, in others 4. In places in the south it grows on the road sides. Our Government has turned to hemp in the past to meet a need. During the would wars the Fed ordered the growing of Hemp and supplied the seeds. Why not now to ease the oil problem?

Posted by: Jay Location: Reno
The best and cheapest source of ethanol would be to buy it from Brazil. It is much cheaper to make it from sugar cane. The goverment should buy it for a strategic reserve. Even with shipping cost, it would be around 1.83 a gallon...

Posted by: John Ross Location: Fernley
EtoH (chemical composition of ethanol) based fuel is not only more expensive to produce, but is more volatile and less stable to store, pump, or use in a vehicle. Let alone the ethanol burns at rate hundreds of times faster than fossil fuels, storage and mileage will be significantly reduced. As for bio-diesel, as soon as a market is found for reused household oils or vegetable oils look out for highest costs at the markets and the pumps. If only a few have it, it will cost you more to get it. The only real solution is to declare fossile fuel usage and supply a national emergency, drill and refine our own here in the U.S. with regulations set by the government. This interferes with 'free' market and capitalism, but a few million bankruptcies would move America from recession to depression. We would be dependant on other countries for everything. Think about the recent tomatoe scare...

Posted by: Lindsey Location: 21206
200 miles to the gallon of cellulosic fuel or ethanal in electric powered vehicles seems to be the ultimate solution to global climate and transportation problems. Try convincing current politicians and those heavily invested in oil for almost a hundred years to support an obviously sane alternative energy solution. War or the vote is the only way this is going to happen.

Posted by: Kathleen Bianchi Location: Fernley
I've been reading about people who pick up waste vegetable/canola oil from restaurants. Why not set up used Vegetable Oil Stations. We could all donate our used oil, and charge say, $2.35 a gallon to keep the Stations in business. Sitting around doing nothing sure isn't changing anything!